Workers’ Compensation Insurance for Contractors
California & Texas
Most contractors think workers’ compensation is just another insurance policy.
It’s not.
Workers’ compensation is the most expensive financing contract in your business and it’s one of the few insurance policies you can actually control if you understand how it works.
At Contractors Insurance Pros, we specialize in helping contractors in Texas and California understand, control, and reduce workers’ compensation costs through education, action, and measurable results.
Workers’ compensation rules vary by state.
In California, workers’ compensation coverage is required for virtually all employers with at least one employee. In Texas, coverage is optional under state law but frequently required by general contractors, project owners, and client contracts.
We help contractors in both states understand these differences and structure workers’ comp programs that meet compliance requirements without overpaying.
The Truth About Workers’ Comp Costs
Insurance companies don’t “pay” for employee injuries, they finance them back to you
For every dollar a workers’ comp carrier pays in claims, contractors typically pay $2–$5 back over time through increased premiums.
Why?
Because workers’ comp costs don’t stop when the claim is closed. They ripple through your pricing for three full policy years via your Experience Modification Factor (X-Mod).
That means:
- One claim today affects your premiums for years
- Multiple small claims can be worse than one large claim
- The real cost of a claim is often hidden from contractors
Most contractors never see this impact until we show them.
Workers’ Comp Is the Insurance You Can Control the Most
If you and your agent spend less time on workers’ comp than any other policy you buy, you’re almost guaranteed to be overpaying.
In our experience:
- Errors in the workers’ comp system cause overcharges in roughly 1 out of 2 businesses
- Most contractors don’t know:
- How their premium is calculated
- How their Experience Mod is calculated
- Which levers they can actually pull to reduce costs
Education is the first pillar of our process for a reason.
How Workers’ Compensation Premium Is Really Calculated
Your workers’ compensation premium is not random. It is driven by four core components:
1. Base Rates
Rates assigned to each job classification based on risk. Every carrier has their own base rates for each class code and this is the only piece you are checking when "shopping".
2. Payroll
The amount of payroll assigned to each classification.
3. Experience Modification Factor (X-Mod)
Your loss history compared to similar businesses.
4. Schedule Modifications
Credits or debits applied by the carrier based on qualitative factors.
Each of these components can be verified, corrected, and influenced if you know what to look for.
Most contractors never review them together in one place. We do.
Experience Mods: Where Most Contractors Lose the Most Money
Your Experience Mod is not just a number.
It is a mathematical formula driven by:
- Claim frequency
- Claim severity
- Expected losses for your trade
- Actual losses incurred
- Loss limitations
- Primary vs excess losses
Most contractors:
- Have never seen their full mod worksheet
- Don’t know how individual claims impact their mod
- Don’t know which claims matter most
We walk clients through
exactly how their mod arrived at its current number, and what can realistically be done about it.
The Hidden Impact on Profit & Sales
An increase in workers’ comp premiums doesn’t just affect your expenses, it affects your entire business model.
For example:
If workers’ comp costs increase by $80,000 per year:
- At a 10% profit margin, you need $800,000 in new sales just to break even
- At a 15% margin, over $530,000 in sales
- At a 20% margin, $400,000 in sales
That’s real work, real risk, real labor, just to pay for insurance inefficiencies.
Most contractors never look at workers’ comp this way. We make sure they do.
The True Cost of Claims (3-Year Impact)
Workers’ comp claims don’t just cost what the carrier pays.
Each dollar of claims typically costs contractors multiple dollars over a three-year rating period.
During our reviews, we show:
- Each individual claim
- How it impacts your Experience Mod
- What it costs you over 1, 2, and 3 years
- Which claims matter most and which matter less
This is often the moment when contractors realize why their premiums “never seem to go down.”
Frequently Asked Questions About Workers’ Compensation Insurance for Contractors
What does workers’ compensation insurance cover?
Workers’ compensation insurance is designed to provide benefits to employees who suffer work-related injuries or illnesses. Coverage may include medical expenses, wage replacement, and other statutory benefits, subject to state law and policy terms.
Is workers’ compensation insurance required for contractors?
Workers’ compensation requirements vary by state and depend on factors such as employee count, business structure, and type of work performed. Many contractors are required by law or contract to carry workers’ compensation insurance.
Who is considered an employee under workers’ compensation?
Employee status is determined by state law and specific working relationships. Misclassification of workers — particularly independent contractors — is a common issue and can lead to uncovered claims, penalties, or audit disputes.
Are subcontractors covered under my workers’ compensation policy?
Subcontractors are typically responsible for carrying their own workers’ compensation insurance. If a subcontractor does not maintain proper coverage, the hiring contractor may be held responsible for injuries under certain state laws.
Does workers’ compensation cover owner-operators or business owners?
Coverage for owners, partners, and corporate officers varies by state and business structure. Some may be required to be included, while others may be eligible to opt out, subject to state rules and insurer approval.
What is employers’ liability insurance, and how is it different from workers’ compensation?
Employers’ liability coverage is typically included within a workers’ compensation policy. It is designed to address certain third-party claims related to employee injuries that are not covered by statutory workers’ compensation benefits, subject to policy terms.
How are workers’ compensation premiums calculated for contractors?
Premiums are generally based on payroll, job classifications, experience modification factors, and state-specific rating rules. Final premiums are typically determined after a policy audit.
What is a workers’ compensation audit, and why does it matter?
A workers’ compensation audit reviews payroll, classifications, and operations to determine the final premium. Errors in classification, payroll reporting, or subcontractor documentation are common causes of unexpected premium increases.
Does workers’ compensation cover injuries that happen off the jobsite?
Coverage generally applies to injuries arising out of and in the course of employment. Whether an injury is covered depends on the specific facts of the incident and applicable state law.
How does workers’ compensation interact with general liability and umbrella coverage?
Workers’ compensation addresses employee injury claims, while general liability addresses third-party claims. Employers’ liability coverage within a workers’ compensation policy may interact with umbrella or excess liability coverage if properly scheduled, subject to policy terms.
What are common workers’ compensation issues contractors overlook?
Common issues include worker misclassification, incorrect class codes, lack of subcontractor certificates, audit preparation errors, and failure to coordinate employers’ liability limits with umbrella or excess liability coverage.
Our 3-Pillar Workers’ Comp Program
We don’t sell workers’ comp the way most agencies do.
Our program is built on three pillars:
Pillar 1: Education
We believe informed contractors make better decisions.
We educate our clients on:
- How workers’ comp pricing actually works
- How Experience Mods are calculated
- Which levers they can and cannot control
- How claims truly impact cost
This education is foundational to everything else we do.
Pillar 2: Action — The Comp Heroes™ Process
Education alone doesn’t reduce premiums. Action does.
Our Comp Heroes™ Process includes:
- Experience Mod (X-Mod) analysis and verification
- Classification and payroll review
- Injury reporting process review
- Nurse triage implementation
- Return-to-work / light duty planning
- Clinic relationship strategy
- Claims management coordination
- Subcontractor compliance review
- Audit preparation
- Ongoing workers’ comp service standards
We don’t implement everything at once. We build a 12-month action plan based on your business.
Pillar 3: Results
Results are measurable.
Our goal is to:
- Reduce claim frequency
- Control claim severity
- Improve Experience Mods over time
- Stabilize workers’ comp costs
- Eliminate preventable overcharges
We track progress and adjust the plan as your business evolves.
What Is an Experience Mod Review?
An Experience Mod Review is a structured analysis of your workers’ compensation data that identifies:
- Errors
- Missed opportunities
- Cost drivers
- Actionable improvements
It requires:
- Your Experience Mod Worksheet
- A conversation about how your business actually operates
Once contractors go through this review, they understand:
- Why their workers’ comp costs are what they are
- What can realistically be changed
- What cannot
-
This is the point where most of our clients decide to move forward.
Who This Is a Good Fit For
- Contractors with employees
- Contractors using subcontractors
- Businesses with rising mods or premiums
- Companies frustrated by audits
- Contractors who want control not just quotes
Request an Experience Mod Review
If you want to understand what your workers’ comp is really costing you, and what can be done about it, start with an Experience Mod Review.
Once we have your worksheet, we’ll walk you through it and show you exactly where the opportunities are.
Coverage availability, terms, and conditions vary by insurer and policy form. All coverage is subject to underwriting approval and the actual policy language.
